马超;孙群;徐青;温伯威;

• 1:信息工程大学

摘要(Abstract)：

针对志愿者地理信息的质量评价问题,对当前的研究现状和存在问题进行了较为全面的综述。有关志愿者地理信息数据质量分析与评估的研究也是该领域的研究热点,国内外学者从不同的角度进行了研究,依据是否使用参考数据分为基于参考数据的方法和基于数据分析的方法。总结了基于参考数据方法的基本流程,论述了两种评价方法中具有代表性的研究成果,分析了这些方法的特点和不足,最后指出了现有研究中存在的问题和进一步需要研究的方向。

关键词(KeyWords)： 志愿者地理信息;空间数据质量;数据质量评价;质量元素

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金项目(41471336)

作者(Authors): 马超;孙群;徐青;温伯威;

DOI: 10.16251/j.cnki.1009-2307.2017.03.017

参考文献(References)：

• [1]张红平,顾学云,熊萍,等.志愿者地理信息研究应用进展与趋势[J].地理信息世界,2012,8(4):67-71.(ZHANG Hongping,GU Xueyun,XIONG Ping,et al.Development and application of volunteered geographic information[J].Geomatids World,2012,8(4):67-71.)
• [2]GOODCHILD M F.Citizens as sensors:the world of volunteered geography[J].GeoJournal,2007,69(4):211-221.
• [3]李德仁,钱新林.浅论自发地理信息的数据管理[J].武汉大学学报:信息科学版,2010,35(4):379-383.(LI Deren,QIAN Xinlin.A brief introduction of data management for volunteered geographic information[J].Geomatics and Information Science of Wuhan University,2010,35(4):379-383.)
• [4]GOODCHILD M F.Data models and data quality:problems and prospects.environmental modeling with GIS[M].New York:Oxford University Press,1993:94-103.
• [5]VAN Oort.Spatial data quality:from description to application[D].Wageningen:WageningenUniversity,2006.
• [6]CHRISMAN N.Development in the treatment of spatial data quality.Fundamentals of spatial data quality elements[M].London:ISTE;21-30.
• [7]单杰,秦昆,黄长青,等.众源地理数据处理与分析方法探讨[J].武汉大学学报:信息科学版,2014,39(4):390-394.(SHAN Jie,QIN Kun,HUANG Changqing,et al.Methods of crowd sourcing geographic data processing and analysis[J].Geomatics and Information Science of Wuhan University,2014,39(4):390-394.)
• [8]刘大杰,刘春.GIS空间数据不确定性与质量控制的研究现状[J].测绘工程,2001,10(1):6-10.(LIU Dajie,LIU Chun.The status of researching on uncertainty of spatial data and quality control in GIS[J].Engineering of Surveying and Mapping,2001,10(1):6-10.)
• [9]吴芳华,吉国杰,曹亚妮.矢量地图数据缺陷识别方法研究[J].测绘科学技术学报,2014,31(3):294-299.(WU Fanghua,JI Guojie,CAO Yani.Research on the defect automatic identification methods of vector map data[J].Journal of Geomatics Science and Technology,2014,31(3):294-299.)
• [10]HAKLAY M.How good is volunteered geographical information?A comparative study of openstreetmap and Ordnance Survey datasets[J].Environment and Planning B:Planning and Design,2010,37(4):682-703.
• [11]ATHER A.A quality analysis of openstreetmap data[D].London:University College London,2009.
• [12]CIEPLUCH B,MOONEY P.Sketches of generic framework for quality assessment of volunteered geographical data[J].IEEE geoscience and remote sensing society,2011.
• [13]HELBICH M,AMELUNXEN C.Comparative spatial analysis of positional accuracy of openstreetmap and proprietary geodata[J].Angewandte Geoinformatik,2010(4):24-33.
• [14]GIRRES J,TOUYA G.Quality assessment of the French openstreetmap dataset[J].Trans GIS,2010,14:435-459.
• [15]LUDWIG I,VOSS A.A comparison of the street networks of navteq and OSM in Germany in advancing geoinformation scienced of a Changing world lecture notes[J].Geoinformation and Cartography 2011(9):65-84.
• [16]ALBAKRI M,FAIRBAIRN D.Assessing the accuracy of“Crowsourced”data and its integration with official spatial data sets[C]//In proceedings of the ninth international sysmposium on spatial accuracy assessment in natural resources and environment sciences,[S.l.]:[s.n.],2010:317-320.
• [17]MARCO H,CHRISTOF A.Comparative spatial analysis of positional accuracy of openstreetmap and proprietary geodata[J].Geovizualisation,2012.
• [18]ROBERTO C,PEGGY A.A photogrammetric approach for assessing positional accuracy of openstreetmap roads[J].Geo-Information,2013(2):276-301.
• [19]王明,李清泉,胡庆武,等,面向众源开放街道地图空间数据的质量评价方法[J].武汉大学学报:信息科学版,2013,38(12):1490-1494.(WANG Ming,LI Qingquan,HU Qingwu,et al.Quality analysis on crowd sourcing geographic data with open street map data[J].Geomatics and Information Science of Wuhan University,2013,38(12):1490-1494.)
• [20]ZHENG Shudan,ZHENG Jianghua.Assessing the completeness and positional accuracy of openstreetmap in China[M].Thematic Cartgraphy for the Society,Springer,2014.
• [21]KOUNADI O.Assessing the quality of openstreetmap data[D].London:University College of London,2009.
• [22]ZIELSTRA D,ZIPF A.A comparative study of proprietary geodata and volunteered geographic information for Germany[C]//Proceedings of 13th AGILE international conference on geographic information science,[S.l.]:[s.n.],2010:10-14.
• [23]KOUKOLETSOS T,HAKLAY M.An automated method to assess data completeness and positional accuracy of openstreetmap[J].GeoComputation,2011:236-241.
• [24]MOHAMMAD F,MAHMOUD R.A quality study of the openstreetmap dataset for Tehran[J].Geo-Information,2014(3):750-763.
• [25]HAKLAY M,BASIOUKA S.How many volunteers does it make to map an area well?The validity of Linus′s law to volunteered geographic information[J].The Cartographic Journal,2010,47(4):315-322.
• [26]ARSANJANI J J,BARRON C.Assessing the quality of openstreetmap contributors together with their contributions[J].AGILE,2013(5):1,4-17.
• [27]赵肄江,周晓光.地理信息志愿者信誉度评估的版本相似度模型:以面目标为例[J].测绘学报,2015,44(5):578-584.(ZHAO Yijiang,ZHOU Xiaoguang.Version similarity-based model for volunteers′reputation of volunteered geographic information:A case study of polygon[J].Acta Geodaetica et Cartographica Sinica,2015,44(5):578-584.)
• [28]MOONEY P,CORCORAN P.Towards quality metrics for openstreetmap[C]//In proceedings of the 18th SIGSPATIAL international conference on advances in geographic information systems,[S.l.]:[s.n.],2010:11.
• [29]PASCAL N,ZIELSTRA D.Comparison of volunteered geographic information data contributions and community development for selected world regions[J].Future Internet,2013(5):282-300.