于海若,宫辉力,陈蓓蓓,刘凯斯

• 1:首都师范大学三维信息获取与应用教育部重点实验室
• 2:首都师范大学城市环境过程与数字模拟国家重点实验室培育基地
• 3:首都师范大学资源环境与旅游学院

摘要(Abstract)：

针对京津冀地区在经济快速发展的同时逐渐成为我国地面沉降灾害的重灾区的现状,该文分析了京津冀地区(北京、天津、河北)地面沉降多年研究成果,对地面沉降形成与发育历史、监测技术、影响因素及驱动机理、预测与风险评价进行探讨。京津冀地区地面沉降研究在基础理论和技术方法方面得到发展的同时,更加注重理论模型的探索和新技术新方法的实践。在对监测技术和实践应用成果分析基础上,认为区域地面沉降目前仍存在研究基础不足和研究能力薄弱现象并存的局面;在沉降监测中最优算法的选取,影响因素分析的综合化、定量化,模型的应用在未来有待于进一步探究。

关键词(KeyWords)： 地面沉降;京津冀;进展;思考

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金面上项(41771455/D010702);; 北京自然科学基金面上项目(8182013);; 北京学者项目;; 国家“双一流”建设高校项目

作者(Author): 于海若,宫辉力,陈蓓蓓,刘凯斯

DOI: 10.16251/j.cnki.1009-2307.2020.04.018

参考文献(References)：

• [1]BERTOLDI G L.Where do we go fran here:a new initiative for subsidence research in the United States[C]∥GRA 1995Annual Meeting.[S.l.]:[s.n.],1995．
• [2]HU R L,YUE Z Q,WANG L C,et al.Review on current status and challenging issues of land subsidence in China[J].Engineering Geology,2004,76(1/2):65-77．
• [3]CHAUSSARD E,WDOWINSKI S,CABRAL-CANOE,et al.Land subsidence in central Mexico detected by ALOS InSAR time-series[J].Remote Sensing of Environment,2014,140:94-106．
• [4]PHIEN-WEJ N,GIAO P H,NUTALAYA P.Land subsidence in Bangkok,Thailand[J].Engineering Geology,2006,82(4):187-201．
• [5]CHAUSSARD E,AMELUNG F,ABIDIN H,et al.Sinking cities in Indonesia:ALOS PALSAR detects rapid subsidence due to groundwater and gas extraction[J].Remote Sensing of Environment,2013,128:150-161．
• [6]TEATINI P,TOSI L,STROZZI T,CARBOGNIN L,et al.Resolving land subsidence within the Venice lagoon by Persistent Scatterer SAR Interferometry[J].Physics and Chemistry of the Earth,Parts A/B/C,2012,40-41:72-79．
• [7]COLOMBO D,FARINA P,MORETTI S,et al.Land subsidence in the Firenze-Prato-Pistoia basin measured by means of spaceborne SAR interferometry[C]∥Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium.[S.l.]:IEEE,2003．
• [8]RAUCOULES D,LE MOULIC S,CARNEC C,et al.Urban subsidence in the city of Prato(Italy)monitored by satellite radar interferometry[J].International Journal of Remote Sensing,2003,24(4):891-897．
• [9]王佳杰．动物园交通枢纽地区地下步行系统的分析与评价[J]．建筑与设备，2013(4):11-15.(WANG Jiajie.Analysis and evaluation of underground walking system in zoo transportation hub area[J].Architecture and Equipment,2013(4):11-15．）
• [10]张博夫，赵志峰，王辉．不良地质条件对天津城市建设的影响研究[J]．城市，2017(2):53-58.(ZHANGBofu,ZHAO Zhifeng,WANG Hui.Study on the influence of bad geological conditions on Tianjin urban construction[J].City,2017(2):53-58．）
• [11]张进才，褚立峰，肖震，等．河北平原地面沉降调查与监测主要进展及成果[J]．中国地质调查，2014,1(2):45-50.(ZHANG Jincai,CHU Lifeng,XIAO Zhen,et al.Main progress and achievements of land subsidence survey and monitoring in Hebei Plain[J].Geological Survey of China,2014,1(2):45-50．）
• [12]李树鹏，王玺，卞德隆，等．河北平原地面沉陷地质问题的研究[J]．资源信息与工程，2016,31(5):182-183.(LI Shupeng,WANG Xi,BIAN Delong,et al.Study on geological problems of ground subsidence in Hebei Plain[J].Resource Information and Engineering,2016,31(5):182-183．）
• [13]周毅，罗郧，郭高轩，等．冲洪积平原地面沉降特征及主控因素：以北京平原为例[J]．地质通报，2016,35(12):2100-2110.(ZHOU Yi,LUO Yun,GUOGaoxuan,et al.A study of the characteristics of land subsidence and the main control factors in the alluvial plain:a case study of Beijing plain[J].Geological Bulletin of China,2016,35(12):2100-2110．）
• [14]LEI K C,LUO Y,CHEN B B,et al.Optimization design of land subsidence levelling network of Beijing Plain[J].Geology in China,2016,43(4):1457-1467．
• [15]杨艳，贾三满，罗勇，等．北京地面沉降工作分析及展望[J]．城市地质，2012,7(2):9-13.(YANG Yan,JIASanman,LUO Yong,et al.Analysis and outlook of the land subsidence in Beijing[J].Urban Geology,2012,7(2):9-13．）
• [16]吕潇文，宋利，邵兴，等．天津市地面沉降监测技术应用及发展建议[J]．上海国土资源，2017,38(2):26-30.(LYU Xiaowen,SONG Li,SHAO Xing,et al.The suggestion and application of land subsidence monitoring in Tianjin[J].Shanghai Land and Resources,2017,38(2):26-30．）
• [17]YU L,YANG T L,ZHAO Q,et al.The 2015-2016ground displacements of the Shanghai coastal area inferred from a combined COSMO-SkyMed/Sentinel-1DInSAR analysis[J].Remote Sensing,2017,9:1194-1213．
• [18]FERRETTI C,ROCCA F.Permanent scatters InSARinterferometry[J].IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing,2001,39(1):8-20．
• [19]宫辉力，张有全，李小娟，等．基于永久散射体雷达干涉测量技术的北京市地面沉降研究[J]．自然科学进展，2009,19(11):1261-1266.(GONG Huili,ZHANGYouquan,LI Xiaojuan,et al.Land subsidence research in Beijing based on permanent scatterer radar interferometry[J].Progress in Natural Science,2009,19(11):1261-1266．）
• [20]ZHOU C D,GONG H L,ZHANG Y Q,et al.Spatiotemporal evolution of land subsidence in the Beijing Plain 2003-2015 using persistent scatterer interferometry(PSI)with multi-Source SAR data[J].Remote Sensing,2018,10:552-572．
• [21]雷坤超，陈蓓蓓，宫辉力，等．基于PS-InSAR技术的天津地面沉降研究[J]．水文地质工程地质，2013,40(6):106-111.(LEI Kunchao,CHEN Beibei,GONG Huili,et al.Detection of land subsidence in Tianjin based on PS-InSAR technology[J].Hydrogeology and Engineering Geology,2013,40(6):106-111．）
• [22]雷坤超，贾三满，陈蓓蓓，等．基于PS-InSAR技术的廊坊市地面沉降监测研究[J]．遥感技术与应用，2013,28(6):1114-1119.(LEI Kunchao,JIA Sanman,CHENBeibei,et al.Land subsidence detection based on PS-InSAR in Langfang[J].Remote Sensing Technology and Application,2013,28(6):1114-1119．）
• [23]ZHOU H,WANG Y,YAN S,et al.Study on land subsidence in Cangzhou area based on sentinel-1A/Bdata[J].International Archives of the Photogrammetry,Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences,2017,XLII-2/W7:675-682．
• [24]张又又．基于时序InSAR技术的天津郊区地面沉降监测应用[J]．城市勘测，2016(6):65-69.(ZHANGYouyou.Application of ground subsidence monitoring in Tianjin suburb based on multi temporal InSAR[J].Urban Geotechnical Investigation&Surveying,2016(6):65-69．）
• [25]张子文，杨帆，吴文豪，等．地下水开采与地面沉降关系的短基线集分析[J]．测绘科学，2016,41(6):64-69,134.(ZHANG Ziwen,YANG Fan,WU Wenhao,et al.Study of land subsidence and groundwater on SBAS time-series analysis[J].Science of Surveying and Mapping,2016,41(6):64-69,134．）
• [26]GUO J M,HU J Y,LI B,et al.Land subsidence in Tianjin for 2015to 2016revealed by the analysis of Sentinel-1Awith SBAS-InSAR[J].Journal of Applied Remote Sensing,2017,11(2):24-26．
• [27]周旭，许才军，温扬茂．利用时序InSAR技术分析北京及河北廊坊地面沉降[J]．测绘科学，2017,42(7):89-93.(ZHOU Xu,XU Caijun,WEN Yangmao.Land subsidence monitoring of Beijing and Langfang of Hebei Province by time series InSAR[J].Science of Surveying and Mapping,2017,42(7):89-93．）
• [28]周超凡，宫辉力，陈蓓蓓，等．北京市典型地区地面沉降空间格局分析[J]．遥感信息，2017,32(4):24-29.(ZHOU Chaofan,GONG Huili,CHEN Beibei,et al.Spatial pattern of land subsidence in Beijing typical areas[J].Remote Sensing Information,2017,32(4):24-29．）
• [29]周超凡，宫辉力，陈蓓蓓，等．北京地面沉降时空分布特征研究[J]．地球信息科学学报，2017,19(2):205-215.(ZHOU Chaofan,GONG Huili,CHEN Beibei,et al.2017.Study of temporal and spatial characteristics of land subsidence in Beijing[J].Journal of Geoinformation Science,2017,19(2):205-215．）
• [30]张永红，吴宏安，康永辉．京津冀地区1992-2014年三阶段地面沉降InSAR监测[J]．测绘学报，2016,45(9):1050-1058.(ZHANG Yonghong,WU Hongan,KANGYonghui.Ground Subsidence over Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region during three periods of 1992to 2014monitored by interferometric SAR[J].Acta Geodaetica et Cartographica Sinica,2016,45(9)1050-1058．）
• [31]李广宇，张瑞，刘国祥，等．Sentinel-1A TS-DInSAR京津冀地区沉降监测与分析[J]．遥感学报，2018,22(4):633-646.(LI Guangyu,ZHANG Rui,LIUGuoxiang,et al.Land subsidence detection and analysis over Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei area based on Sentinel-1A TS-DInSAR[J].Journal of Remote Sensing,2018,22(4):633-646．）
• [32]郑佳荣，宫辉力，李青元，等．基于PS-InSAR土体的2003-2009年北京平原区沉降控制因素分析[J]．测绘通报，2014(12):40-43.(ZHENG Jiarong,GONGHuili,LI Qingyuan,et al.The control factors on subsidence of Beijing Plain area in 2003-2009based on PS-InSAR technology[J].Bulletin of Surveying and Mapping,2014(12):40-43．）
• [33]雷坤超，罗勇，陈蓓蓓，等．北京平原区地面沉降分布特征及影响因素[Jl．中国地质，2016,43(6):2216-2225.(LEI Kunchao,LUO Yong,CHEN Beibei,et al.Distribution characteristics and influence factors of land subsidence in Beijing area[J].Geology in China,2016,43(6):2216-2225．）
• [34]徐佳，王巍，韦劲松，等．天津市区地面沉降多因素分析[J]．地下水，2012,34(4):205-207.(XU Jia,WANGWei,WEI Jinsong,et al.Multi-factor analysis of land subsidence in Tianjin urban area[J].Ground water,2012,34(4):205-207．）
• [35]李曼，葛大庆，张玲，等．基于PS-InSAR技术的唐山南部沿海地区地面沉降研究[J]．工程地质学报，2016,24(4):704-712.(LI Man,GE Daqing,ZHANG Ling,et al.Land subsidence of coastal area in southern Tangshan using PS-InSAR technology[J].Journal of Engineering Geology,2016,24(4):704-712．）
• [36]赵国敏，赵根模，陈宇坤，等．天津海河断裂活动性研究[M]．北京：地震出版社，2006:17-29.(ZHAOGuomin,ZHAO Genmo,CHEN Yukun,et al.Study on the activity of Haihe fault in Tianjin[M].Beijing:Seismological Press,2006:17-29．）
• [37]白晋斌，牛修俊．天津新生界固结特征与地面沉降[J]．中国地质灾害与防治学报，2010,21(1):42-46.(BAIJinbin,NIU Xiujun.Cenozoic consolidation characteristics and land subsidence in Tianjin[J].The Chinese Journal of Geological Hazard and Control,2010,21(1):42-46．）
• [38]牛修俊．地层的固结特性与地面沉降临界水位控沉[J]．中国地质灾害与防治学报，1998,9(2):68-74.(NIU Xiujun.Characteristics of strata consolidation and land subsidence controlling by critical water level[J].The Chinese Journal of Geological Hazard and Control,1998,9(2):68-74．）
• [39]杨艳，王荣，罗勇．北京典型地面沉降区土体压缩特征研究[J]．现代地质，2016,30(3):716-722.(YANGYan,WANG Rong,LUO Yong.A study on soil compression characteristics in land subsidence areas within Beijing[J].Geoscience,2016,30(3):716-722．）
• [40]田芳，郭萌，罗勇，等．北京地面沉降区土体变形特征[J]．中国地质，2012,39(1):236-242.(TIAN Fang,GUO Meng,LUO Yong,et al.The deformation behavior of soil mass in the subsidence area of Beijing[J].Geology in China,2012,39(1):236-242．）
• [41]主灿，张云，何国峰，等．天津滨海新区抽水引起地面沉降现场试验研究[J]．水文地质工程地质，2018,45(2):159-164.(ZHU Can,ZHANG Yun,HE Guofeng,et al.In-situ tests of land subsidence caused by pumping in the Tianjin Binhai New Area[J].Hydrogeology and Engineering Geology,2018,45(2):159-164．）
• [42]杨吉龙，袁海帆，胡云壮，等．天津滨海地区深部黏土层弹塑性变形特征与地面沉降关系研究[J]．岩土力学，2018,39(10):3763-3772.(YANG Jilong,YUANHaifan,HU Yunzhuang,et al.Relationship between elastoplastic deformation of deep clay and land subsidence in the Tianjin coastal area[J].Rock and Soil Mechanics,2018,39(10):3763-3772．）
• [43]朱菊艳．沧州地区地面沉降成因机理及沉降量预测研究[D]．北京：中国地质大学（北京），2014.(ZHUJuyan.Research on land subsidence mechanism and prediction of settlement in Cangzhou area[D].Beijing:China University of Geosciences(Beijing),2014．）
• [44]CHEN B B,GONG H L,LI X J,et al.Characterization and causes of land subsidence in Beijing,China[J].International Journal of Remote Sensing,2017,38(3):808-826．
• [45]姜媛，贾三满，王海刚．北京地面沉降风险评价与管理[J]．中国地质灾害与防治学报，2012,23(1):55-60.(JIANG Yuan,JIA Sanman,WANG Haigang.Risk assessment and management of land subsidence in Beijing Plain[J].The Chinese Journal of Geological Hazard and Control,2012,23(1):55-60．）
• [46]吴凯，于静洁，谢贤群．河北南部平原地下水位变化趋势及其对农业生态环境的影响[J]．农业环境保护，2001,20(6):401-404.(WU Kai,YU Jingjie,XIEXianqun.Changing tendency of groundwater level and its effects on agro-ecological environment in the south of Hebei Plain[J].Agro-environmental Protection,2001,20(6):401-404．）
• [47]潘云，潘建刚，宫辉力，等．天津市区地下水开采与地面沉降关系研究[J]．地球与环境，2004,32(2):36-39.(PAN Yun,PAN Jiangang,GONG Huili,et al.Research on the relationship between groundwater exploitation and subsidence in Tianjin proper[J].Earth and Environment,2004,32(2):36-39．）
• [48]田芳，罗勇，周毅，等．北京地面沉降与地下水开采时空演变对比[J]．南水北调与水利科技，2017,15(2):163-169.(TIAN Fang,LUO Yong,ZHOU Yi,et al.Contrastive analysis of spatial-temporal evolution between land subsidence and groundwater exploitation in Beijing[J].South-to-North Water Transfers and Water Science and Technology,2017,15(2):163-169．）
• [49]杨勇，郑凡东，刘立才，等．北京平原区地下水水位与地面沉降关系研究[J]．工程勘察，2013(8):44-48.(YANGYong,ZHENG Fandong,LIU Licai,et al.Study on the correlation between groundwater level and ground subsidence in Beijing Plain area[J].Geotechnical Investigation and Surveying,2013(8):44-48．）
• [50]张文杰．沧州市地面沉降与开采地下水关系初探[J]．地下水，2010,32(6):41-42.(ZHANG Wenjie.Preliminary study on the relationship between land subsidence and groundwater exploitation in Cangzhou[J].Ground Water,2010,32(6):41-42．）
• [51]刘明坤，寇文杰，罗勇，等．北京市地面沉降与地下水开采关系分析[J]．城市地质，2016,11(1):21-25.(LIUMingkun,KOU Wenjie,LUO Yong,et al.Analysis of the relationship between land subsidence and groundwater exploitation in Beijing[J].Urban Geology,2016,11(1):21-25．）
• [52]GAO Mingliang,GONG Huili,CHEN Beibei,et al.Regional land subsidence analysis in eastern Beijing Plain by InSAR time series and wavelet transforms[J].Remote Sensing,2018,10(3):365-382．
• [53]LUO Z J,ZENG F.Finite element numerical simulation of land subsidence and groundwater exploitation based on Visco-elasticplastic Biot’s consolidation theory[J].Journal of Hydrodynamics,2011,23(5):615-624．
• [54]JIANG L M,BAI L,ZHAO Y,et al.Combining InSAR and hydraulic head measurements to estimate aquifer parameters and storage variations of confined aquifer-system in Cangzhou,North China Plain[J].Water Resources Research,2018(54):8234-8252．
• [55]GONG H L,PAN Y,ZHENG L Q,etal.Long-term groundwater storage changes and land subsidence development in the North China Plain(1971-2015)[J].Hydrogeology Journal,2018,26:1417-1427．
• [56]刘元章，武强，林沛，等．从地下水赋存运移规律的再认识谈北京平原地面沉降发生的另一原因[J]．水文，2013,33(4):37-44.(LIU Yuanzhang,WU Qiang,LINPei,et al.Discussion on mechanism of land subsidence based on restudying storage and circulation law of quaternary groundwater in Beijing plain[J].Journal of China Hydrology,2013,33(4):37-44．）
• [57]DU Z Y,GE L L,NG A H M,et al.Mapping land subsidence over the eastern Beijing city using satellite radar interferometry[J].International Journal of Digital Earth,2018,11(5):504-519．
• [58]罗立红，白晋娬，吕潇文，等．基于长期监测的天津市地面沉降影响分析[J]．上海国土资源，2017,38(2):18-21.(LUO Lihong,BAI Jinwu,LYU Xiaowen,et al.Tianjin land subsidence influence factor quantization analysis based on long-term monitoring data[J].Shanghai Land and Resources,2017,38(2):18-21．）
• [59]CHEN B B,GONG H L,LI X J,et al.Spatial correlation between land subsidence and urbanization in Beijing,China[J].Natural Hazards,2015,75(3):2637-2652．
• [60]ZHU L,GONG H L,LI X J,et al.Land subsidence due to groundwater withdrawal in the northern Beijing Plain,China[J].Engineering Geology,2015,193:243-255．
• [61]AN K.Investigating the relationship between land subsidence and groundwater depletion in the North China Plain using GRACE and ICESat[D].Los Angeles:University of California,Los Angeles,2015．
• [62]姜媛，王荣，田芳，等．北京地区地面沉降与地裂缝关系研究[J]．城市地质，2014,9(4):6-10.(JIANG Yuan,WANG Rong,TIAN Fang,et al.Study on the relationship between land subsidence and ground fissures in Beijing[J].Urban Geology,2014,9(4):6-10．）
• [63]王寒梅．上海地面沉降风险评价及防治管理区建设研究[J]．上海地质，2010,31(4):7-11,17.(WANGHanmei.Study on risk evaluation and control schemes of land subsidence in Shanghai city[J].Shanghai Geology,2010,31(4):7-11,17．）
• [64]房浩，何庆成，赵婷婷，等．沧州市地面沉降风险评价指标体系构建研究[J]．上海国土资源，2014,35(2):9-12,20.(FANG Hao,HE Qingcheng,ZHAO Tingting,et al.Construction of a risk assessment index system for land subsidence in Cangzhou city[J].Shanghai Land and Resources,2014,35(2):9-12,20．）
• [65]王坤．天津宁河县地面沉降危险性评价[J]．西部资源，2015(4):113-115.(WANG Kun.Land subsidence risk assessment of Ninghe County,Tianjin[J].Western Resources,2015(4):113-115．）
• [66]邢一飞．沧州地面沉降影响因素分析及预测评价研究[D]．北京：中国矿业大学，2017.(XING Yifei.Study on influence factors,prediction and evaluation of land subsidence in Cangzhou[D].Beijing:China University of Mining and Technology,2017．）
• [67]田宝柱，陶志刚，李昌存．唐山沿海地区地面沉降科学计算与预测[J]．金属矿山，2011(5):101-105.(TIANBaozhu,TAO Zhigang,LI Changcun.Scientific computing and forecasting to land subsidence in coastal region of Tangshan[J].Metal Mine,2011(5):101-105．）
• [68]LI Y Y,GONG H L,ZHU L,et al.Measuring spatiotemporal features of land subsidence,groundwater drawdown,and compressible layer thickness in Beijing Plain,China[J].Water,2017,9:64-81.